Shelter Island, NY Fishing Report

Latest fishing conditions for Shelter Island. 8 species reported with 2 local guides available.

Plan a Trip to Shelter Island

See what's biting in Shelter Island, find top-rated guides, and estimate charter costs.

Plan Your Trip

Featured Charters in Shelter Island

Tubby Charters

5(8)Top Rated

inshore

Shelter Island, New York

East End Sport Fishing LLC

5(11)Top Rated

Join Captain D for a thrilling fishing charter on Eastern Long Island. Experience trophy fish and family fun from April to December. Book today!

Shelter Island, New York

What's Biting By Month

Peak

1 / 2

Nearby Fishing Cities

Montauk

New York

29 Charters

Brooklyn

New York

12 Charters

Freeport

New York

9 Charters

Dunkirk

New York

3 Charters

East Hampton

New York

3 Charters

Huntington

New York

2 Charters

Fire Island

New York

0 Charters

Long Beach

New York

0 Charters

Fish Species in Shelter Island

Weakfish

Flounder

Tuna

Mahi Mahi

Black Sea Bass

Tautog

Are you a fishing guide in Shelter Island?

Join our directory free in 2026 — starting 2027, listings are $99/year.

Get Listed Free in 2026