FishingCharterFinder Logo

Old Tappan, NJ Fishing Trip — May

Your Old Tappan, NJ Fishing Trip

May2 peopleFamily Trip
High 69°F / Low 53°F7.6" rain · 19 rainy daysMild weather — bring layers for cool mornings on the water.

What’s Biting in May

Largemouth BassExcellent
Largemouth Bass
Spinning · Baitcasting
Smallmouth BassExcellent
Smallmouth Bass
Casting · Fly Fishing
WalleyeExcellent
Walleye
Various
Northern PikeExcellent
Northern Pike
Various

May Weather in Old Tappan

69°F
Avg High
53°F
Avg Low
7.6"
Rainfall
19
Rainy Days

Mild weather — bring layers for cool mornings on the water.

53 Guides Near Old Tappan

No guides are based in Old Tappan, but these guides operate nearby.

View all guides
Chasin' Tail Sportfishing - Chasin' Tail Sportfishing
Chasin' Tail Sportfishing

Chasin' Tail Sportfishing

5(147)Top Rated

chasin' tail sportfishing, chasin' tail

Port Monmouth, New Jersey
Misty Morn Fishing Boat - Misty Morn Fishing Boat
Misty Morn Fishing Boat

Misty Morn Fishing Boat

4.6(88)Top Rated

The Misty Morn specializing in Raritan Bay party boat fishing along with large group fishing charters.

South Amboy, New Jersey
Salty Dog Watersport Charters - Salty Dog Watersport Charters
Salty Dog Watersport Charters

Salty Dog Watersport Charters

5(51)Top Rated

Salty Dog Watersports is a premier watersports charter on the Jersey Shore. We offer wakesurfing, waterskiing, tubing, wakeboarding, sunset cruises, dock and dine, special events and more!

Highlands, New Jersey
MI-JO Charter Fishing and Cruises - MI-JO Charter Fishing and Cruises
MI-JO Charter Fishing and Cruises

MI-JO Charter Fishing and Cruises

4.7(65)Top Rated
Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey
Jenna P Sportfishing - Jenna P Sportfishing
Jenna P Sportfishing

Jenna P Sportfishing

4.9(46)Top Rated

Jenna P Sportfishing is a private fishing charter and guide service out of the Sandy Hook Marina in Highlands, NJ. Fish for striped bass, fluke and more.

FlukeStriped Bass
Highlands, New Jersey
Keyport Princess - Keyport Princess
Keyport Princess

Keyport Princess

4.6(47)Top Rated

The Keyport Princess is New Jerseys premier North Jersey Head Boat Fishing and Cruising vessel. Family owned and operated offering the finest fishing experience for all anglers.

Keyport, New Jersey
Kill Shot Charters LLC - Kill Shot Charters LLC
Kill Shot Charters LLC

Kill Shot Charters LLC

4.9(33)Top Rated

Captain Gabe is a USCG certified Captain. He has been fishing the NJ and NY waters for his whole life along with his first mate Ryan. Call or text Gabe at (732) 608-4077 or visit www.KillShotCharters.net for more information or to book a charter.

Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey
Just Sayin Sportfishing Charters - Just Sayin Sportfishing Charters
Just Sayin Sportfishing Charters

Just Sayin Sportfishing Charters

4.9(30)Top Rated
inshore
Keyport, New Jersey
Lake Hopatcong Guide Service - Lake Hopatcong Guide Service
Lake Hopatcong Guide Service

Lake Hopatcong Guide Service

4.7(29)Top Rated
Lake Hopatcong, New Jersey
Canyon Eagle III - Canyon Eagle III
Canyon Eagle III

Canyon Eagle III

4.8(25)Top Rated

At Canyon Eagle 1 LLC, we offer the ultimate fishing charter in New Jersey. Out of Belmar, we invite you to join us for an unforgettable charter fishing experience that will last a lifetime. Fishing Charter New Jersey

Perth Amboy, New Jersey
Teal Cruises - Teal Cruises
Teal Cruises

Teal Cruises

4.8(25)Top Rated

The Motor Yacht Teal is available for private charter as well as open cruises from Atlantic Highlands NJ and NYC. The Teal can accommodate up to 75 guests. Teal Cruises in Atlantic Highlands

Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey
Reel Happy Fishing Charters - Reel Happy Fishing Charters
Reel Happy Fishing Charters

Reel Happy Fishing Charters

5(19)Top Rated

Reel Happy - Sandy Hook Fishing Charters Raritan Bay Fishing Charters. Fishing The Inshore and Near Shore Water Of Raritan Bay and Sandy Hook NJ

Highlands, New Jersey
View all 53 guides
$910
Estimated total for 2 people
$455
per person
Charter $500
Tip $100
Licenses $60
Food $100
Lodging $150

Estimates based on local charter rates and averages. Contact guides for exact pricing.

What's Biting By Month

Peak

Largemouth Bass

freshwater
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D

Smallmouth Bass

freshwater
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D

Walleye

Various
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D

Northern Pike

Various
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D

Also Consider Fishing In...

Point Pleasant Beach18 guides · 64 miBelmar15 guides · 58 miHighlands15 guides · 43 miAtlantic Highlands8 guides · 42 miBrick Township7 guides · 66 miKeyport7 guides · 42 mi

What to Bring

Check with your guide about what gear is provided. Here's a recommended packing list:

Essentials

  • Sunscreen (SPF 50+)
  • Polarized sunglasses
  • Hat or visor
  • Weather-appropriate clothing
  • Non-marking shoes or deck shoes

Food & Personal

  • Water and drinks (stay hydrated)
  • Snacks or lunch
  • Cooler for your catch
  • Motion sickness medication (if needed)
  • Camera or phone (waterproof case recommended)
  • Valid fishing license (confirm with captain)

For inshore Fishing

  • Light rain jacket

New Jersey Fishing License

License Cost
Resident$22.50
Non-Resident$34
Requirements

Required for ages 16-69. Trout stamp additional. Separate saltwater registry (free).

Buy License Online — New Jersey

Species Regulations

Largemouth Bass
Season:Year-round
Bag Limit:5 per day
Size Limit:12-inch minimum

Check the current NJ Freshwater Fishing Digest for specific waterbody exceptions, including catch and release areas.

Smallmouth Bass
Season:Year-round
Bag Limit:5 per day
Size Limit:12-inch minimum

Specific regulations may apply to certain waters, so consult the NJ Fish and Wildlife Digest.

Walleye
Season:Year-round
Bag Limit:3 per day
Size Limit:18-inch minimum

Check the current NJ Freshwater Fishing Digest for specific waterbody exceptions.

Northern Pike
Season:Year-round
Bag Limit:2 per day
Size Limit:24-inch minimum

Check the current NJ Freshwater Fishing Digest for specific waterbody exceptions.

Start Over