Brooklyn, NY Fishing Trip — May

Your Brooklyn, NY Fishing Trip

May2 peopleFamily Trip

High 67°F / Low 55°F7.8" rain · 17 rainy daysMild weather — bring layers for cool mornings on the water.

What’s Biting in May

8 species

Mahi Mahi

Excellent

Mahi Mahi

Various

Striped Bass

Excellent

Striped Bass

Trolling · Casting

Black Sea Bass

Excellent

Black Sea Bass

Bottom Fishing · Jigging

Bluefish

Excellent

Bluefish

Trolling · Casting

Tuna

Excellent

Tuna

Trolling · Chunking

Tautog

Excellent

Tautog

Bottom fishing · Jigging

Flounder

Excellent

Flounder

Various

Weakfish

Good

Weakfish

Various

May Weather in Brooklyn

67°F

Avg High

55°F

Avg Low

7.8"

Rainfall

17

Rainy Days

Mild weather — bring layers for cool mornings on the water.

12 Guides Matched

Marilyn Jean IV Brooklyn Fishing Boat

Marilyn Jean Fishing offers memorable fishing trips around NYC for first-timers to the most experienced anglers.

Brooklyn, New York

Gypsea Fishing Charters

4.9(134)Top Rated

Brooklyn, New York

Capt. Dave Fishing

Sailing Daily from Pier 3 2498 Emmons Ave. Sheepshead BayBrooklyn, NY 11235 Fish with the best, not with the rest! Book online now! Sailing for Blackfish, Cod, Ling. Every Day 8:00am – 4:00pm Live crabs provided! Contact us for the offshore Tuna trips in August and September. For additional information, general inquiries, or to book groups.

Black Sea BassCodSheepshead

Brooklyn, New York

Ocean Eagle V

4.5(110)Top Rated

Ocean Eagle V is a private vessel docked in Sheepshead Bay, NY equipped with navigation and safety equipment. Visit our site to book a trip now.

Brooklyn, New York

Midnight Fleet

Welcome to Midnight Fleet. Join our experienced crew for a deep sea fishing adventure in Sheepshead Bay, NY.

Brooklyn, New York

Hunter Fishing

4.8(62)Top Rated

Brooklyn, New York

Lady Flamingo

4.5(67)Top Rated

Fishing Brooklyn NY, lady flamingo

Brooklyn, New York

FATBACK Charters

Professional fishing charter service in Brooklyn, New York. Contact us to book your next fishing adventure!

Brooklyn, New York

Bank Tank Charters

Brooklyn, New York

Karen Ann Charters

Brooklyn, New York

Whatta Catch Sport Fishing & Charter Boat

Whatta Catch Sport Fishing is a full service charter boat sailing from Brooklyn, NY. We fish year round for species ranging from striped bass, fluke, sharks, and tuna.

FlukeSharksStriped Bass

Brooklyn, New York

Goin Fishin Charters

Brooklyn, New York

Brooklyn, New York

Prepare for Your Trip

Gear recommendations and packing list for your trip. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

For Your Target Species

Medium Heavy Spinning Setup

Versatile rod and reel for casting to mahi on the surface

Shop on Amazon →

Striper Bucktail Jig

White bucktail jigs tipped with pork rind — classic striper catcher

Shop on Amazon →

For Inshore Fishing

Performance Fishing Shirt

UPF 50+ long sleeve — stay cool and protected all day

Shop on Amazon →

Sun protection for face and neck that breathes in the heat

Shop on Amazon →

For the Season

Waterproof Backpack

Keeps electronics and gear dry in downpours and spray

Shop on Amazon →

Anti-Fog Sunglasses Spray

Keep polarized lenses clear in humid and rainy conditions

Shop on Amazon →

Trip Essentials

Saltwater-resistant pliers with split ring tool and line cutter

Shop on Amazon →

Waterproof Dry Bag

Roll-top bag for phone, wallet, and keys — keeps everything dry

Shop on Amazon →

What to Bring

Check with your guide about gear. Here's a recommended packing list:

Sunscreen (SPF 50+)

Polarized sunglasses

Hat or visor

Weather-appropriate clothing

Non-marking shoes or deck shoes

Water and drinks (stay hydrated)

Snacks or lunch

Cooler for your catch

Motion sickness medication (if needed)

Camera or phone (waterproof case recommended)

Valid fishing license (confirm with captain)

Light rain jacket

$910

Estimated total for 2 people

$455

per person

Charter $500

Tip $100

Licenses $60

Food $100

Lodging $150

Brooklyn from ~$150/night

Pickup in Brooklyn

Estimates based on local charter rates and averages. Contact guides for exact pricing.

Things to Do in Brooklyn

Activities for your non-fishing days

Boat Tours & Cruises

Snorkeling & Diving

Kayaking & Paddleboarding

Wildlife & Nature Tours

What's Biting By Month

Peak

1 / 2

Mahi Mahi

Striped Bass

Weakfish

Black Sea Bass

New York Fishing License

License Cost

Resident$25

Non-Resident$50

Requirements

Required for ages 16+. Freshwater fishing only. Marine registry separate and free.

Buy License Online — New York

Species Regulations

Mahi Mahi

Season:Year-round

Bag Limit:3 per person

Size Limit:No size limit

No more than 15 mahi mahi may be possessed aboard a vessel at any time.

Striped Bass

Season:Check DEC website for current season dates

Bag Limit:1 per angler

Size Limit:28-31 inch slot limit

Regulations can change frequently; always check the NYS DEC website for the most up-to-date information.

Black Sea Bass

Season:Check DEC website for current season dates

Bag Limit:Check DEC website for current bag limit

Size Limit:16-inch minimum

Regulations can change frequently; always check the NYS DEC website for the most up-to-date information.

Bluefish

Season:Check DEC website for current season dates

Bag Limit:3 per angler

Size Limit:No minimum size limit

Regulations can change frequently; always check the NYS DEC website for the most up-to-date information.

Also Consider Fishing In...

Babylon11 guides · 36 mi Freeport9 guides · 19 mi New Rochelle5 guides · 23 mi New York4 guides · 12 mi Bronx3 guides · 20 mi Oceanside3 guides · 15 mi