Shelter Island, NY Fishing Trip — September

Yacht Hampton Boat Rental

5(289)Top Rated

Yacht Hampton has the largest selection of NEW boats & yachts for rent in the Hamptons. View over 30 NEW boats today! Text/Call 631-500-7777.

Fin Chaser

4.8(211)Top Rated

MONTAUK DEEP SEA FISHING JOIN OUR FISHING FAMILY! HOOK UP on the FIN CHASER! 2025 FISHING REPORTS Our Trip Schedules https://youtu.be/d9QAqT068M0 A FIN-TASTIC EXPERIENCE!

Viking Fleet

4.4(683)

Welcome to the Viking Fleet, the world's largest & most diversified fishing fleet open to the public in Montauk, Tarpon Springs, & Sag Harbor. Book now!

Rosie Fishing

4.8(142)Top Rated

Professional fishing charter service in Center Moriches, New York. Contact us to book your next fishing adventure!

Osprey Fishing

4.7(159)Top Rated

Osprey Fishing Fleet located on Long Island NY in Port Jefferson Harbor features 2 large fishing charter boats, Osprey and Osprey V fully equipped to catch fluke, porgies, bass, bluefish, weakfish, blackfish, and striped bass. Available for Private Charters and Sunset Cruises.

White Water Outfitters

4.6(118)Top Rated

Here at WWO, we’ve brought together several top professionals in the industry and local experts with one purpose in mind – to give you the most comprehensive & successful fishing experience possible! Our staff here at the shop is a seasoned team of fishing professionals including captains, guides, and mates. Our

Kopis Charters

5(60)Top Rated

Experience Montauk’s #1 fishing charter or sunset cruise. Our charters & cruises offer an unforgettable adventure & guaranteed amazing fishing. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ rated.

Captain Fish Port Jefferson

5(54)Top Rated

25 Lb Striped bass Mixed Bag LONG ISLAND, LONG ISLAND SOUND, PORT JEFFERSON (631)

My Joyce Charters- Montauk Fishing Charters

5(50)Top Rated

My Joyce Fishing Charters in Montauk, NY is a private charter boat for the whole family! Private Charters for striped bass, fluke, shark, tuna and more!