Second Choice Charters
Captain Second Choice Charters
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I book a trip with Second Choice Charters?
Contact Second Choice Charters directly by phone at 631-466-7223 or by email at [email protected]. It's best to book in advance, especially during peak fishing season.
What should I bring on the trip?
Check with Second Choice Charters about what gear is provided. Generally, you should bring sunscreen, sunglasses, a hat, non-marking shoes, food and drinks, and a cooler for your catch.
What fish can I catch with Second Choice Charters?
Montauk, New York is known for "Striped Bass, Bluefish, Flounder, Black Sea Bass, Tautog. Contact Second Choice Charters for current conditions and what's biting.
Do I need a fishing license?
In most cases, your fishing license is covered under the captain's charter license in New York. However, regulations vary so it's best to confirm with Second Choice Charters when booking.
What to Bring
Check with Second Choice Charters about what gear is provided. Here's a recommended packing list:
Essentials
- Sunscreen (SPF 50+)
- Polarized sunglasses
- Hat or visor
- Weather-appropriate clothing
- Non-marking shoes or deck shoes
Food & Personal
- Water and drinks (stay hydrated)
- Snacks or lunch
- Cooler for your catch
- Motion sickness medication (if needed)
- Camera or phone (waterproof case recommended)
- Valid fishing license (confirm with captain)
For inshore Fishing
- Light rain jacket
Get in Touch
Contact Second Choice Charters to check availability and book your trip.
Quick Info
- inshore
Is this your business?
Claim your profile to update information, add photos, trip rates and access free tools to grow your guide business.
Free to claim • No credit card required
Popular Fish Species in Montauk, New York
Montauk, New York offers excellent fishing opportunities for a variety of species. Popular fish in this area include "Striped Bass, Bluefish, Flounder, Black Sea Bass, Tautog, Weakfish, Mahi-Mahi, Tuna", Arctic Grayling, and Atlantic Halibut. Book a charter with Second Choice Charters to target these species and more with expert local guidance.
Are you a fishing guide?
Join our directory and get access to free tools to grow your business.
Other Charters in Montauk
View All →Fishooker Charter Service
Montauk, New York
Momentum Charters
Montauk, New York
My Joyce Charters- Montauk Fishing Charters
My Joyce Fishing Charters in Montauk, NY is a private charter boat for the whole family! Private Charters for striped bass, fluke, shark, tuna and more!