Bonnethead Shark Fishing in Montauk, NY
Local guides, seasonality, and regulations for bonnethead shark in Montauk.
Fishing Charters in New York
Browse fishing charters in New York that can help you catch bonnethead shark.
Momentum Charters
Montauk, New York
Captain Nick Charters
Hampton Bays, New York
I'm Capt. Nick I do fishing charters in Suffolk County on Long Island. Fluke, striped bass, bluefish, and bay sunset cruises
Tide Hustle
Greenport, New York
Tide Hustle is an open boat and private charter fishing boat in Greenport, NY. Tide Hustle fishes for porgies, weakfish, striped bass, blackfish and other local fish. You can buy a single ticket or book the whole boat!
Lake Runner Charters
Hamlin, New York
Lake Runner charters offers Private Group and Family Fishing Charters for up to 6 passengers. Fishing Lake Ontario New York for Salmon, Trout, Kings and more.
Rebel Fishing Charters
Hilton, New York
Zrg Fishing
Chaumont, New York
Second Choice Charters
Montauk, New York
Nova Sport Fishing
Dunkirk, New York
Knot Right Fishing Charter
Westfield, New York
Fishooker Charter Service
Montauk, New York
Dixons To The Point Charters
East Hampton, New York
Fly Fishing in Montauk and the Florida Keys
Fin Alley Fishing Charters
Hampton Bays, New York
Fin Alley is an offshore fishing charter boat in Long Island, NY that targets bluefin tuna, yellowfin tuna, big eye tuna, albacore, mahi, and marlin.
Best Time to Catch Bonnethead Shark
Peak season: May, June. Also good: April, July, August.
Seasonal Activity Chart
Bonnethead Shark
The Bonnethead Shark, easily recognized by its distinctive shovel-shaped head, is a fascinating and accessible shark species that provides exciting angling opportunities. Found in coastal waters along the Atlantic and Gulf coasts, as well as parts of the Pacific, Bonnetheads are relatively small compared to other shark species, making them a great target for anglers new to shark fishing. They are particularly abundant in areas like the Florida Keys, the Carolinas, and the Gulf of Mexico, offering readily available action and a unique fishing experience.
Bonnethead Shark Fishing in Montauk
Believe it or not, bonnethead sharks can be found as far north as Montauk, New York, during the warmer months. While not as common as further south, their presence offers a unique angling opportunity. The late summer and early fall, when water temperatures peak, are the best times to target them. Look for them in the bays and inlets, especially around areas with structure or abundant baitfish. Drifting with live or cut bait is a proven technique. Montauk's strong currents and rocky bottom structure mean you'll need heavier tackle than you might use in Florida. A sturdy spinning or conventional setup with a wire leader is essential. Since they are not a primary target species here, be prepared for a bit of a challenge. Local tip: Check with local tackle shops for the most up-to-date information on bonnethead sightings. Also, practice catch and release to help maintain the population in this northern range.
Plan a Trip to Montauk
See what's biting in Montauk, find top-rated guides, and estimate charter costs.
How to Catch Bonnethead Shark
Bonnethead Shark Fishing Regulations in New York
Open Season
Year-round
Daily Bag Limit
No limit
Size Limit
No size limit
License Required
Recreational Marine Fishing Registry
Anglers must enroll in the Recreational Marine Fishing Registry. Check for any specific advisories or closures before fishing.
⚠️ Always verify current regulations with the New York state wildlife agency before fishing.
Related Species in New York
Frequently Asked Questions
When is the best time to catch Bonnethead Shark in Montauk, NY?
The best months for Bonnethead Shark in Montauk are May, June.
What are the Bonnethead Shark fishing regulations in New York?
In New York, the season is year-round, the daily bag limit is No limit, the minimum size is No size limit. Regulations change throughout the year, so confirm current rules with the New York wildlife agency before fishing.
Do I need a fishing license to catch Bonnethead Shark in New York?
Recreational Marine Fishing Registry. On a guided charter, anglers are often covered under the captain's license — confirm with your guide when booking.
Other Species to Fish in Montauk
Ready to Catch Bonnethead Shark in Montauk?
Book a trip with an expert guide who knows the best local spots and techniques.