Finetooth Shark Fishing in Montauk, NY

While Montauk is better known for its larger shark species, Finetooth Sharks do make an appearance, offering a unique light-tackle challenge. The key is timing: target them during the warmest months, typically July and August, when water temperatures are at their peak. Look for them in the warmer inshore waters and bays, where they follow schools of baitfish. Unlike offshore shark fishing, targeting Finetooth Sharks here often involves smaller boats and lighter gear. Drifting with live or cut bait is a popular method. A local tip: Shinnecock Bay can be a productive area, particularly around the inlets and channels. Be aware of strong currents and boat traffic. The Finetooth Shark population in Montauk is relatively small compared to other areas, but they are present and can provide a fun diversion from targeting larger gamefish. Always practice responsible catch and release.